RETRACTED: A Bacterium That Can Grow by Using Arsenic Instead of Phosphorus
type: Thing
description: scientific article published in 2010 in Science and retracted in 2025
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P31
  value: retracted paper
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P31
  value: scholarly article
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P50
  value: Felisa Wolfe-Simon
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P50
  value: Gwyneth W Gordon
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P50
  value: Jennifer Pett-Ridge
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P189
  value: Mono Lake
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P275
  value: all rights reserved
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P304
  value: 1163-1166
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P356
  value: 10.1126/SCIENCE.1197258
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P407
  value: English
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P433
  value: 6034
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P478
  value: 332
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P577
  value: December 2, 2010
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P698
  value: 21127214
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P793
  value: retraction notice
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P921
  value: GFAJ-1
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P921
  value: arsenate ion
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P921
  value: phosphate(3−) ion
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P953
  value: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1197258
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P1433
  value: Science
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P1476
  value: RETRACTED: A Bacterium That Can Grow by Using Arsenic Instead of Phosphorus
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2093
  value: J. S. Blum
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2093
  value: T. R. Kulp
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2093
  value: S. E. Hoeft
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2860
  value: A biological function for cadmium in marine diatoms
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2860
  value: Bacillus arsenicoselenatis, sp. nov., and Bacillus selenitireducens, sp. nov.: two haloalkaliphiles from Mono Lake, California that respire oxyanions of selenium and arsenic
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P2860
  value: Poly(β-hydroxybutyrate) production by a moderate halophile, Halomonas boliviensis LC1
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P3181
  value: 4372674
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P3931
  value: American Association for the Advancement of Science
additional property: PropertyValue
  property ID: P5530
  value: 10.1126/SCIENCE.1197258
confidence:
  popularity graph score:
    score: 0.001
    score pct: 0
    tier: established
    components:
      sitelinks: 0
      sitelinks norm: 0.0
      unique citations: 9
      unique citations norm: 0.004
      monthly pageviews: 1
      monthly pageviews norm: 0.0
  sitelinks: 0
  unique citations: 9
  monthly pageviews: 1
  yearly pageviews: 9
  pageview trend:
    m: 2026-08
    v: 1
  pageview trend:
    m: 2026-07
    v: 2
  pageview trend:
    m: 2026-06
    v: 6
  tier: established
claims:
  P31:
    value: Q45182324
    source count: 3
    confidence: 0.6
    value label: retracted paper
    qualifiers:
      P580: +2025-07-00T00:00:00Z
  P31:
    value: Q13442814
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: scholarly article
  P50:
    value: Q441568
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Felisa Wolfe-Simon
  P50:
    value: Q89857543
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Gwyneth W Gordon
  P50:
    value: Q87972480
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Jennifer Pett-Ridge
  P50:
    value: Q535733
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Paul Davies
  P50:
    value: Q61742385
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Ariel D. Anbar
  P189:
    value: Q335585
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: Mono Lake
  P275:
    value: Q1752207
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: all rights reserved
  P304:
    value: 1163-1166
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P356:
    value: 10.1126/SCIENCE.1197258
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P407:
    value: Q1860
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: English
  P433:
    value: 6034
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P478:
    value: 332
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P577:
    value: +2010-12-02T00:00:00Z
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P698:
    value: 21127214
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
  P793:
    value: Q7316896
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: retraction notice
  P921:
    value: Q212837
    source count: 1
    confidence: 0.2
    value label: GFAJ-1

value: Q409221
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: arsenate ion

value: Q177811
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: phosphate(3−) ion

value: Q7430
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: deoxyribonucleic acid

value: Q674
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: phosphorus

value: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1197258
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: Q192864
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: Science

value: RETRACTED: A Bacterium That Can Grow by Using Arsenic Instead of Phosphorus
source count: 2
confidence: 0.4

value: J. S. Blum
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: T. R. Kulp
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: S. E. Hoeft
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: J. F. Stolz
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: S. M. Webb
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: Q24678882
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: A biological function for cadmium in marine diatoms

value: Q31943109
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: Bacillus arsenicoselenatis, sp. nov., and Bacillus selenitireducens, sp. nov.: two haloalkaliphiles from Mono Lake, California that respire oxyanions of selenium and arsenic

value: Q60015931
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: Poly(β-hydroxybutyrate) production by a moderate halophile, Halomonas boliviensis LC1

value: Q37588100
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: The microbial arsenic cycle in Mono Lake, California

value: Q80172212
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: Arsenic resistance and removal by marine and non-marine bacteria

value: 4372674
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2

value: Q40358
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: American Association for the Advancement of Science

value: 10.1126/SCIENCE.1197258
source count: 0
confidence: 0.0

value: Q135476119
source count: 0
confidence: 0.0

value: 49654131
source count: 0
confidence: 0.0

value: Q1147312
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: NASA Astrobiology Institute

value: Q50423863
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: copyrighted

value: Q232932
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: open access

value: Q232932
source count: 1
confidence: 0.2
value label: open access

value: 15A56CDEC5BCE71AAEF81ED9A2EB99
source count: 0
confidence: 0.0

pub year: 2025
retrieved: 2025-07-27

pub year: 2010
retrieved: 2025-03-02

source: Crossref
stated in qid: Q5188229
retrieved: 2017-04-20

source: Crossref
stated in qid: Q5188229
retrieved: 2021-01-07

source: COCI
stated in qid: Q107507940
retrieved: 2025-07-26

pub year: 2025
retrieved: 2025-07-27

source: Retraction Watch
stated in qid: Q17078233
retrieved: 2025-08-19

source: PubMed
stated in qid: Q180686
retrieved: 2022-09-19

source: Consolidated OpenCitations Corpus – April 2017
stated in qid: Q30068043

wikidata id: Q21706159
domain: retracted_paper
level: standard
html url: https://4ort.xyz/entity/retracted-a-bacterium-that-can-grow-by-using-arsenic-instead-of-phosphorus
markdown url: https://4ort.xyz/entity/retracted-a-bacterium-that-can-grow-by-using-arsenic-instead-of-phosphorus.md
facts url summary: https://4ort.xyz/entity/retracted-a-bacterium-that-can-grow-by-using-arsenic-instead-of-phosphorus/facts.json
facts url standard: https://4ort.xyz/entity/retracted-a-bacterium-that-can-grow-by-using-arsenic-instead-of-phosphorus/facts.json
facts url full: https://4ort.xyz/entity/retracted-a-bacterium-that-can-grow-by-using-arsenic-instead-of-phosphorus/facts.json
data source: Wikidata (CC0 / public domain)
license: https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
api version: v1
served at: 2026-08-14T04:16:08.719307Z
entity updated at: 2026-05-03T21:19:00.258443+00:00Z
entity created at: 2026-05-03T14:12:18.107337+00:00Z